Current Value

$ %
Click here for full rankings...

All time Rating

$ %
Click here for full rankings...

Are Celtic Too Good for Scotland?

Published on August 29, 2015

By adammcenroe, Contributor for Soccerjury


If you are a follower of Scottish footballer, you will no doubt have noticed that there has been an uproar to the comments made by Glasgow Celtic assistant manager, John Collins.

Collins, who played 58 times for Scotland and made over 200 appearance for the Hoops as a player, claimed that the domestic opposition do not have “clever enough players or quick enough thinkers to punish us”. 

As you might imagine, these barbed comments have caused a major stir in Scotland – but is the straight talking assistant manager really wrong? Or, are Celtic simply too good for Scotland?

John Collins has been the assistant manager of Celtic since June 2014 (SNS Group)

In Defence of John Collins

First off, let me admit that I’m a massive fan of John Collins. An absolutely tremendous footballer, and a man who knows what it takes to be professional and how to win. Collins was certainly clever enough and quick enough to damage teams in his day.

His domineering performances at club and international level make him one of the standout Scots of the last thirty or so years, and his achievements as a manager should not be forgotten either.

John Collins celebrates scoring against Brazil in the 1998 World Cup (Getty)

A spell abroad with Charleroi before returning to Scotland to manage Hibernian were short but fruitful. He even won a trophy at Hibernian and was instrutmental in the development of some very talented players at the time.

Aberdeen manager Derek McInnes sniped that Collins had “a lot to say for an assistant manager” but McInnes seems to have totally sidestepped two key points;

  • Collins has done as much in just two seasons as a manager than McInnes has so far achieved.
  • McInnes, following a 3-0 win in Croatia against Rijeka, stated that nobody in Scotland would “test their discipline” like they were tested in Croatia

How can you possibly make such a fuss against someone with comparative achievements as a manager and far more accomplishments as a player, and treat him as if he was a nobody? This is ridiculous grandstanding from the Dons manager. Given he made similar remarks too, his own comments smack of hypocracy.

Dennis McInnes has reacted strongly to John Collins comments (BBC)

In my opinion, Collins was completely right in what he said. It was a bit crass, sure, but it is the truth. Just this week alone, Inverness boss John Hughes more or less echoed these sentiments whilst Ryan Stevenson of Partick Thistle stated that Celtic defender Virgil Van Dijk was “above” the Scottish divisions.

Is it only when a Celtic staff member makes such comments that it can be construed as arrogant?

“The Bayern of Scotland”

One stinging criticsm from fans of other SPFL teams is that there is little wonder Celtic dominate so much when they snap up the best of talent in the league. And these accusations have been further fuelled since Celtic's triple transfer of Nadir Ciftci, Stuart Armstrong and Gary Mackay-Steven from Dundee United.

But is it really fair to say Celtic win the league by "poaching" the best players from domestic rivals? Are Celtic really the Bayern Munich of Scotland?

Ciftci's transfer from rivals Dundee United have again led to accusations of Celtic poaching SPFL stars (Scotsman)

Reality is sometimes far from the truth. In fact, Celtic has a chequered record of buying SPL players -  Anthony Stokes, in 2010, was arguably the last significant SPFL singing that they made before this season. Even during the intervening period, fans of other SPFL clubs still accused the Hoops of poaching their way to the top.

Celtic are undeniably in a position of strength and power. Ever since the Fergus McCann era they have created a powerful and dedicated plan towards financial solidity. Their philosophy has been to bring in cheap players from outside Scotland who have the potential to develop and become SPFL stars before selling them for a higher price.

Although fans of Celtic do not see the same calibre of player or find the success in Europe that Bayern fans are accustomed to, both teams are on the same footing when it comes to their relative financial strength versus their domestic rivals and the desire of other teams players to want to play for them.

Fergus McCann has left a sustainable legacy at Celtic that will benefit the Glasgow club for many years (Evening Times)

But is it fair to criticise Celtic for their long term planning and foresight to be in their current financial position of power? Although the big spending days of Martin O’Neill are long gone, the club is arguably one of the healthiest in the continent.

The same really cannot be said for many other teams in Scotland. But Celtic's fiscal prudence (even to the detriment of the playing team at times) has been far more significant in Celtic's success than any perceived "hand-picking" of the league’s best and brightest.

The Fact of the Matter

The fact of the matter is that Celtic, as a football club have been slow to adapt in the last twenty years when football has become so much more global. However, recently their desire to match the biggest teams in Europe for preparation, fitness, tactical acumen, player development has been steadily improving in the last twelve months. And this is in large part due to Celtic manager Ronny Deila.

Look at the work Deila done in his homeland with Stromsgodset. He took what was described as the “Kilmarnock of Norway” to the title! His budget was nearly a tenth of that of perennial big dogs Rosenborg, yet he managed to do it. How? Through coaching, development, fitness, professionalism and a commitment to sticking with a long-term plan.

Hoops manager Ronny Delia is thinking long term at Celtic (Skysports)

Rosenborg are the Celtic of Norway, so it’s not impossible for other SPFL clubs to prove the words of Collins wrong. But they need to find themselves someone with enough foresight and ambition to stay committed to a long-term project. Celtic have simply been smart to avoid a boom-and-bust policy like their great rivals Rangers, and have positioned themselves to maintain their dominance in the SPFL for many years to come.

Things may change if Rangers get promoted and sort themselves out as a football club. And even then there has to be a step change in the level of transparency, vision, and commitment at the Ibrox club since they re-formed in 2012. 

However, until that potential scenario actually unfolds, Collins statements are correct and will remain so for the foreseeable future. 

Rate this article: 1 Vote Up Vote Down 0

Current Rating: 6.05

All Comments (1)

User's photo
Mark Lawes

Fully agree. A club can win even if the odds are stacked against them. Look what Ferguson did with Aberdeen before he joined United.

August 29 at 10:26pm Reply | Flag

Click to rate: 0 Vote Up Vote Down 0

No comments to display.
No comments to display.
Premier League Flashback: Man City 3-2 QPR

Greatest finale ever to an English league season

Article Image
How did Wales become so good?

Tournament outcasts to European heroes

Article Image
Leicester City crowned Champions of England

The fairy-tale is complete

Article Image
Flashback: Keane's Horror Tackle on Haaland

United captain's vengeance

Article Image
The Meteoric Rise of 'little' Leicester City

Relegation fighters to title favourites

Article Image
Why are United struggling?

Analysis of their passing and shooting efficiency versus EPL teams

Article Image
London United XI

A Premier League Dream Team combined from the City's Clubs

Article Image
Faustino Asprilla: Flair, controversy and cult hero status

Signed for Newcastle twenty years ago

Article Image
Top 10 Strikers in World Football Today

Barca forwards dominate inaugural rankings

Article Image
Turbo-charged Liverpool Dismantle City

Red letter day for Anfield Club

Article Image
15/16 European Champions League Draw

Mixed fortunes for English teams

Article Image
Euro 2016 Draw - As it happened

England and Wales to face each other

Article Image
Legendary teams: Hungary 1950-56

The Mighty Magyar's remembered

Article Image
Mourinho: Charting his fall from grace

But does an opportunity exist?

Article Image
Most Astonishing FIFA Rankings Ever

Belgium secure top spot and other ranking surprises

Article Image
Before Sergio There Was Georgi

A tribute to a Man City hero in the club's darkest era

Article Image
Liverpool Sack Manager Brendan Rodgers

Klopp favourite to fill vacant positon

Article Image
How not to stretcher a player from the field!

Comedic scenes in Greek Second Division game

Article Image
Arsene Wenger: Charting the Highs and Lows

Gunners manager enters 20th year at Arsenal

Article Image
Tony Yeboah's Iconic Goal Remembered

Leeds cult hero's wonder strike 20 years ago

Article Image
Are Celtic Too Good for Scotland?

A Hoops fan's verdict to the great debate

Article Image
The day a legend announced himself to the world

Beckham's wonder goal against Wimbledon

Article Image
Clash of the Titans: Ronaldo vs Messi

Who is the greatest player in the world?

Article Image
Why Benteke £32.5m transfer is a huge gamble

Could define Liverpool's future

Article Image
Man Utd 15/16 Home Shirt Launched

Featuring a 300 style launch video

Article Image
Have you seen the Hulk Smash?

Viral videos of Zenit player showcasing his strength

Article Image
Clash of the Titans: Maradona vs Messi

Who is the greatest Argentinian ever?

Article Image
The Greatest England Team of All Time?

The ultimate dream team

Article Image
The Greatest Ever British & Irish XI

Several controversial omissions

Article Image