Current Value

$ %
Click here for full rankings...

All time Rating

$ %
Click here for full rankings...

Why the MLS is no longer just a 'Retirement League'

Updated on October 26, 2015

By LukeChristou, Contributor for Soccerjury


David Beckham became the face of Major League Soccer back in 2007 when he joined LA Galaxy aged 31. This was a move which many experts saw as one last payday for the England icon before he hung up his boots.

The MLS franchise initiated the Designated Player Rule to ensure the England international could join his new club, as it allowed clubs to break their wage structure to land big-name players. But soon after the MLS was discredited as a European 'retirement league', consisting of big-name former internationals well past their prime but commanding a hefty salary.

This summer saw the 'retirement league' phrase resurface, after the likes of Andrea Pirlo, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard all chose to move to the US. All three players were legends in their homeland but had a combined aged of 98 years.

Red Bulls fans mock rivals New York City in their derby game this season (Gazetta)

However, things are now different compared with 2007. Beckham admitted just last week that he was desperate to extend his deal at Real Madrid prior to joining LA Galaxy, only for his proposed contract extension to fall through, leaving him without a club at the end of the season.

This implies that the former England captain considered the MLS his back-up option at the time.

David Beckham's move to the MLS was not his first choice (The Times)

However, this was not the case for Pirlo, Gerrard and Lampard, who all wanted to play in the MLS. Their move was not a last resort, but their desired choice.

Pirlo still had a year remaining on his contract with Juventus, and his 33 appearances in the 14/15 season helped the Italian superclub win another Serie A title and progress to the Champions League final. This proved that the 'Architect' still had enough quality and fitness to continue for at least another season at a major European club, but reports suggested he was desperate for Juventus to cancel his contract to free him to move to the US.

Likewise, Gerrard, albeit in his less favoured defensive-midfield role, was still a vital part of a Liverpool squad lacking in experience and leadership. And Lampard's successful Manchester City loan proved he still had plenty to offer in the Premier League.

The quality of the big-name players is on an upward trend, and they are choosing to join MLS despite having other offers on the table. With stars like Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Cristiano Ronaldo now being linked with moves to MLS, the global appeal of the franchise will only gain further momentum. 

Ibrahimovic and Ronaldo to star in the MLS? (Eurosport)

Also, there is an interesting trend that is now appearing in the MLS. This is the case of players who were unable to shine in Europe, either through a lack of opportunities, loss of form, or bad luck, but who have successfully relaunched their careers in MLS.

The best example is 28 year old Toronto FC striker Sebastian Giovinco who played in Italy's Euro 2016 qualifiers against Azerbaijan and Norway last week. Giovinco was a former Juventus trainee but represented the Turin club in just 92 league games spanning nine years. In his first season in MLS, the Azzurri forward netted 22 league goals in 31 appearances earning himself a recall to the Italy squad.

Coupled with his Italy selection, Giovinco has even emerged as a shock transfer target for La Liga giants Barcelona, and this alone speaks volumes about the progress that MLS has made over recent years.

Likewise, Kaka's resurgence at Orlando City has also ignited speculation of a potential move to the Premier League, with heavyweights Chelsea and Arsenal rumoured to be monitoring the former Ballon d'Or winner.

Sebastian Giovinco reignited his career in the MLS (Toronto FC)

MLS was once considered a place for big names to play out their remaining days in relative comfort against players of a 'lesser standard'. But it has now emerged as a creditable league for players to show-case their talent, and the football quality continues to improve each year.

Also, the number of players from MLS being selected for their national teams is increasing, sparking debate within the league to introduce a much-needed international break similar to Europe.

The MLS franchise adopted the early English Premier League model, which is now similarly bearing fruit. In the Premier League's infancy, Jurgen Klinsmann, Gianfranco Zola and Marcel Desailly were all considered past their prime when they joined the Premier League. Accusations of a 'retirement league' were also directed at the Premier League at the time. 

But these players were the early pioneers in improving the quality and wider appeal of the EPL, and helped dispel this phrase. Will the same be said about Pirlo, Gerrard and Lampard in years to come with reference to MLS?

The Premier League has managed to become the league of choice for many globally, but MLS is following a similary trajectory and continues to gain traction. Is it outside the realms of possibility for MLS to challenge the Premier League one day?

For long gone are the Beckham days, as Major League Soccer enters a new era. 

Rate this article: 2 Vote Up Vote Down 0

Current Rating: 6.10

All Comments (1)

User's photo
Robbie Ackerman

Great article smile Definitely can see MLS challenging the EPL one day. It has a huge amount of potential and the likes of Pirlo, Gerrard and Lampard will only help unlock that.

October 16 at 10:33pm Reply | Flag

Click to rate: 0 Vote Up Vote Down 0

No comments to display.
No comments to display.
Premier League Flashback: Man City 3-2 QPR

Greatest finale ever to an English league season

Article Image
How did Wales become so good?

Tournament outcasts to European heroes

Article Image
Leicester City crowned Champions of England

The fairy-tale is complete

Article Image
Flashback: Keane's Horror Tackle on Haaland

United captain's vengeance

Article Image
The Meteoric Rise of 'little' Leicester City

Relegation fighters to title favourites

Article Image
Why are United struggling?

Analysis of their passing and shooting efficiency versus EPL teams

Article Image
London United XI

A Premier League Dream Team combined from the City's Clubs

Article Image
Faustino Asprilla: Flair, controversy and cult hero status

Signed for Newcastle twenty years ago

Article Image
Top 10 Strikers in World Football Today

Barca forwards dominate inaugural rankings

Article Image
Turbo-charged Liverpool Dismantle City

Red letter day for Anfield Club

Article Image
15/16 European Champions League Draw

Mixed fortunes for English teams

Article Image
Euro 2016 Draw - As it happened

England and Wales to face each other

Article Image
Legendary teams: Hungary 1950-56

The Mighty Magyar's remembered

Article Image
Mourinho: Charting his fall from grace

But does an opportunity exist?

Article Image
Most Astonishing FIFA Rankings Ever

Belgium secure top spot and other ranking surprises

Article Image
Before Sergio There Was Georgi

A tribute to a Man City hero in the club's darkest era

Article Image
Liverpool Sack Manager Brendan Rodgers

Klopp favourite to fill vacant positon

Article Image
How not to stretcher a player from the field!

Comedic scenes in Greek Second Division game

Article Image
Arsene Wenger: Charting the Highs and Lows

Gunners manager enters 20th year at Arsenal

Article Image
Tony Yeboah's Iconic Goal Remembered

Leeds cult hero's wonder strike 20 years ago

Article Image
Are Celtic Too Good for Scotland?

A Hoops fan's verdict to the great debate

Article Image
The day a legend announced himself to the world

Beckham's wonder goal against Wimbledon

Article Image
Clash of the Titans: Ronaldo vs Messi

Who is the greatest player in the world?

Article Image
Why Benteke £32.5m transfer is a huge gamble

Could define Liverpool's future

Article Image
Man Utd 15/16 Home Shirt Launched

Featuring a 300 style launch video

Article Image
Have you seen the Hulk Smash?

Viral videos of Zenit player showcasing his strength

Article Image
Clash of the Titans: Maradona vs Messi

Who is the greatest Argentinian ever?

Article Image
The Greatest England Team of All Time?

The ultimate dream team

Article Image
The Greatest Ever British & Irish XI

Several controversial omissions

Article Image